RIP George Duffy
We've lost a champion for wilderness :(
February 16, 1937-July 8, 2010
Dear family, friends and colleagues,
George died peacefully, the New Mexico sky filled with clouds, wind blowing in the
grasses, the morning air still cool. So many of you traveled to be with him in these
last months, called, sent notes of support, sweet treats, photos, memories of shared
adventures. Thank you for all you did: for making him laugh, for honoring his work, for
supporting us in this challenging time, for caring so deeply. We each knew George
through the particular lens of our relationship with him; we all knew George as a
tireless advocate for the National Wilderness Preservation System. In keeping with
his wishes there will not be a formal memorial service. Instead, George asked that
those wishing to express remembrance of him do so by donating to The New Mexico
Wilderness Allianceâ€”George Duffy Wilderness Protection Endowment Fund, P.O.
Box 25464, Albuquerque, New Mexico, 87125.
I know that each of us will find our own way of honoring George in the days ahead. For
myself, I walk among juniper and pinon and give thanks for his tender heart and deep
passion, his tenacious care, his love of the next adventure, and his unflinching
courage. I give thanks for this precious life that he so loved, for the profound beauty
revealed, moment-to-moment, in all of its complexity and mystery. I give thanks for
Mountainair, New Mexico
I am forwarding to you a letter we recently received from George Duffy, a retired
Forest Service Employee and a letter in response from our Chief, Tom Tidwell.
For those of you that have had the great good fortune to know and work with George,
you already know of his dedication as an employee and of his passion for wilderness.
For those of you that havenâ€™t had that opportunity, you will begin to understand
what George brought to our agency and to wilderness when you read the enclosed â
€œA Letter to My Friends in Wilderness.â€�
George recently sent this letter out to many of his friends in the wilderness
community. Georgeâ€™s observations, musings and reminders are inspiring and
energizing to those of us who play a role in the stewardship of the National
Wilderness Preservation System. The Chief in his letter committed to George to
share his reflections widely. I encourage you to spend a few minutes reading this
letter and to share it with others.
/s/ Joel D. Holtrop
JOEL D. HOLTROP
Deputy Chief, National Forest System
A Letter to My Friends in Wilderness
As my life comes to a close, I feel compelled to express my gratitude to those of you
who have journeyed together with me in wilderness and contributed to my
understanding of wilderness and subsequently of myself.
I hope you will indulge me a few moments as I try to share with you what I have
learned on our journey together.
The Wilderness Act of 1964 marked a turning point in America's attitude toward wild
places. It was an acknowledgement that wild places were not only coming under the
plow and the paving machines, but that their loss by such means was accelerating and
would soon lead to a society impoverished by the loss of the fundamental relationship
between humans and the lands which defined them.
The language of the Act is like few other laws we have enacted. It reads more like
poetry than law and evokes an emotional response which invites introspection and
envisioning of a future expressive of our concern for restraint and accommodation of
other life forms.
This, in contrast to a precise formulaic law was the genius of the Act's principle
author, Howard Zahnizer.
He fixed the concept of wilderness in our minds rather than just in law or on a piece
of real estate - and compelled us to look for and understand the characteristics of
wilderness in our lives as well as in our landscapes.
The Wilderness Act will challenge and enrich scholars, legal experts, wilderness
managers and wilderness advocates for as long as there is wilderness.
We can only hope that the spirit which created this awareness of our place in the
natural order prevails in our thinking.
For, as Joseph Wood Krutch said,
"Wilderness is the permanent home of the human spirit"
Upon passage of the Wilderness Act, the Forest Service developed management
policy and direction to administer this new National Wilderness Preservation System
- Forest Service Manual Section 2320. It consisted of 34 pages. Today it is 55 pages
and in the process of being revised in the WO.
When you hold that Forest Service Manual Section 2320 in your hands, - you hold a
precious symbol of the Forest Service's commitment to America's wilderness - one
which is being challenged by all manner of argument.
Within the agency, there are those who are impatient with the idea of the minimum
tool, - and craft arguments to justify the use of chain saws, trail machines,
jackhammers, helicopters, and other expedients for the sake of convenience or
There are those who are wedded to the idea of mitigating the challenges of
wilderness by constructing improvements, identifying and removing hazards, writing
detailed guidebooks and publishing detailed maps.
There are those who feel that the existing definition of wilderness may be
inappropriate to an evolving social conscience rooted in technology, urbanization and
speed, - and that management must be modified to reflect those changing social
There are those who feel that human intervention in natural processes within
wilderness is necessary when those processes don't fit their perceptions of what is
There are those who hold an anthropocentric rather than biocentric view of
wilderness, - and accordingly suggest that accommodation for human use, rather than
preserving an untrammeled wilderness resource, be the paramount consideration
when shaping wilderness policy.
Outside the agencies, there are those who, in their eagerness to see more public
lands gain the protection of wilderness, - have agreed to legislative provisions which
compromise the wilderness quality of the very lands they wish to preserve as
There are those who think of wilderness as beautiful landscapes or wildlife
sanctuaries or recreation areas rather than as places which integrate the enduring
physical, biological and spiritual dynamics of an untrammeled part of the earth.
The authors of the Wilderness Act held no such views.
They were keenly aware that there were but few remnants of the landscapes which
had shaped the American character, - and they wanted to ensure that these were
preserved in the condition of wildness which confronted and influenced our early
They knew that wilderness had to remain a point of reference in both our natural and
cultural histories, -an enduring benchmark for our journey through time and space,
unchanged by human intervention and subject only to natural forces.
They knew that wilderness was an indispensable part of our humanness and was
critical to our understanding our place in the universe.
Today, the American public can be grateful that you have been vigilant and stood
shoulder to shoulder with the dedicated group of wilderness advocates both within
and outside the public land management agencies, - to assure that these challenges to
wilderness are being resolved in favor of the philosophy so well articulated in the
You are the stewards of America's wilderness and I want to speak to you of
Webster's Dictionary defines a steward as:
" One called to exercise responsible care over the possessions entrusted to him(her)
"One who manages another's property"
I am extremely grateful to you for having chosen to be stewards of these lands. You
have assumed a sacred trust, to be executed with reverence, humility, and a profound
sense of responsibility.
You are not engaged in a business or delivering a product or providing a service or
producing a commodity.
You are engaged in no less than preserving the nation's precious remaining
repositories of wildness and guarding the permanent home of our human spirit.
Over the years, I have watched as the growth and complexity of the National
Wilderness Preservation System have presented you with new stewardship challenges.
You have met those challenges with care and deliberation and resolved them with
uncanny respect for the language and intent of the Wilderness Act
Today, you can be proud that since the passage of the Wilderness Act in 1964, which
designated 9 million acres of Forest Service land as wilderness, the people of the
United States have respected your stewardship and repeatedly petitioned the
Congress to entrust to you the care of more wilderness areas. Their efforts have
placed more than 109 million acres in your care;
You can be proud that the federal land management agencies have created the Arthur
Carhart National Wilderness Training Center to provide training in wilderness
philosophy and wilderness stewardship for federal employees;
You can be proud that the federal land management agencies have created the Aldo
Leopold National Wilderness Research Center to conduct social and biological
research to support and improve wilderness stewardship;
And you can be proud of your role in preserving that "enduring resource of
wilderness" envisioned by the authors of the Wilderness Act.
As you enter another year of wilderness stewardship, please be as caring of
yourselves as you are for wilderness.
Take the time to open yourselves fully to the dynamics of wild landscapes and their
affects on your mind, body and spirit. - Share your passions with your colleagues and
the earth - Become fully alive.
These days you share with wildness are gifts you will treasure forever.
My fondest memories are of those times when nature's influences were most keenly
Being picked up by a gusty ridge top wind and pitched through the air like a rag doll.
Huddled on the lee of a rocky summit during a storm and feeling hypothermia trying
to rob me of my abilities.
Being carried along in the tumbling whiteness of an avalanche.
Walking out of the snow and ice of high mountains and again smelling the green of the
Lying in a sunny meadow and sensing that all the spirits there were filling my being
with strengths unknown and unknowable.
Sensing the unseen presence of the others in the landscape.
Feeling a timeless wisdom trying to order my thoughts to wholeness.
For most of us, our connection with wilderness is commonly understood to be
primarily rooted in the cultural and aesthetic responses which evolved from the
experiences of early explorers and settlers on the new landscapes of America.
We have recently discovered, however, that the underlying basis for our responses to
wilderness goes deeper, - much deeper.
Going to the wilderness is going home.
Anthropologists and others have been suggesting for a long time that we are still the
wild creatures we were in the Pleistocene. We havenâ€™t changed. Only our
circumstances have changed.
Paul Shepard, perhaps the most insightful scholar of the history and evolution of
human ecology has written:
"The discovery of the DNA by Watson and Crick was hailed for its implications for
human health and well being. - Soon it is expected we will be able to create the
perfect banana or the perfect cow and clone it forever. We may soon be able to
change the order of genes in our chromosomes to make us taller, thinner, stronger â
€“ Maybe even less maladapted to our current circumstances."
But more importantly, the mapping of the human genome confirmed that, genetically,
we are still wild, Pleistocene creatures.
Finally, an answer as to why we feel so at home in wilderness.
Shepard declared that:
â€œThe home of our wildness is both etymologically and biologically wilderness.
Although we may define ourselves in terms of culture and language and so on, it is
evident that the context of our being now, as in the past, is wilderness â€“ an
environment lacking domestic plants and animals entirely, and to which, one might say,
our genes look expectantly for those circumstances which are their optimal ambienceâ
â€œThe time is coming â€œ he said â€œto understand the wilderness in its
significance, not as adjunct to the affluent traveler, to an educated, esthetic,
appreciative class, or to thinking of nature as a Noahâ€™s ark in all of its forms, but
as the social and ecological mold of humanity itself, which is fundamental to our
To understand the significance of wilderness, we must take the time to separate
culture from biology, learning from instinct, - and to search deep within for those
ancient gifts which truly inform our humanness.
I have but one request of you.
Go - Find yourself in the wilderness - Be at home.
Let your genes once again find expression in the world that defined them.
Rejoice in your humanness.
You are a genetic library of gifts informed by centuries of life in wilderness.
Gifts from the experiences of antecedent creatures - ichthyian, reptilian and
mammalian which lie still in your brainstem.
Gifts from the struggles of the naked ape with neither fang nor claw who was able,
not only to survive, but to adapt and flourish - simply and elegantly - in wild landscapes.
When we first walk into wilderness, we feel like alien creatures, intruding into the
unknown, - but if we stay a while, usually about a week, and pay attention to ourselves,
those gifts become apparent.
We become aware that our eyes see better - we can pick things out in the landscape
more keenly; we can measure distance more accurately; and shape, color and contrast
are vividly apparent.
Our noses discriminate and identify the odors on the wind, the smell of a bighorn is a
lot different than that of a bear, there is a marsh upwind.
The sounds we heard on our first day came from a general direction but now our
binaural senses are so keen we can almost pinpoint the source and distance of a sound
â€“and identify it.
The awkwardness we first felt when moving over broken ground has been replaced by
a fluid economical rhythm of movement that seems almost effortless.
Our spine flexes, gathering and releasing energy; our pelvis tilts, our center of
gravity is keenly felt and we are again those confident primal animals on the
We sense our relationships with the other creatures with whom we share these
landscapes, relationships which reaffirm our humble role as members of the vast
community of life.
These are not new skills learned, they are ancient abilities recalled - pulled from the
shelves of that genetic library deep within our being.
As we peer into campfire flames, the comfort of thousands of fires, in thousands of
caves, over thousands of years, warm us from the inside as well from the outside.
The diminuendo of the Canyon wren and the raucous scolding of the Stellarâ€™s jay
invite our hearts to sing.
The warmth of the sun and the snap of the cold affirm that we are alive, and
The mountains, the deserts, the storms and the rivers challenge our cunning and
demand our respect.
The vastness of the landscape humbles and fixes us in scale.
As we lie on the earth in the evening, the march of Orion across the heavens fixes us
We are still those Pleistocene creatures - at home and full of the wonder of being.
This is the wildness in our genes, found manifest in a simple, bipedal hominid, -
surrounded by a peace that transcends time, - and in a place we shall always need -
George Duffy, Wilderness Ranger (Retired), Mountainair, New Mexico